top of page

My Spouse Is Self-Employed. How do I know what his or her income is for support?

Writer: Isaac Paonessa
Isaac Paonessa
Nov 7
6 min read
Finding out a self-employed partner's income for support purposes may require extensive information gathering and analysis
Finding out a self-employed partner's income for support purposes may require extensive information gathering and analysis

Your spouse’s tax return reports modest income, but the business pays some expenses, keeps money in the corporation, or seems to support a different lifestyle. Which number should be used for child or spousal support?


The short answer is that taxable income is usually the starting point, not always the final answer. Support income is a legal determination based on the available records, the structure of the business and what money is genuinely available. Sometimes the tax-return figure is fair. Sometimes it needs adjustment. The task is to test it carefully—not to assume that every deduction is improper or that every dollar in a corporation can be withdrawn.


Why self-employed income is harder to read


An employee usually has pay stubs and a T4. A self-employed person may receive salary, dividends, shareholder-loan payments, management fees or benefits. They may leave earnings in a corporation if they're incorporated, pay legitimate business expenses, experience uneven revenue, or have one unusually strong or weak year.


That creates several numbers that are easy to confuse: gross revenue, net business profit, taxable income, cash in the bank and income available for support. They're not interchangeable.


A business can have high revenue and narrow margins. It can also pay expenses that benefit the owner personally. The records and context determine what each number means.


The tax return is the starting point—not always the last word


For child support, the Federal Child Support Guidelines generally begin with total income from the T1 tax return or Notice of Assessment (Line 15000), adjusted for certain exceptions under Schedule III of the Guidelines. If one year does not fairly show the person’s income, a court may consider the last three years and any pattern, fluctuation or non-recurring amount.


Where a spouse is a shareholder, director or officer of a corporation, the court can consider all or part of corporate pre-tax income if personal taxable income does not fairly reflect the money available for child support. The analysis must still account for the business’s real needs. Retained earnings are not automatically available to the owner, but they are not automatically protected from review either.


A court may also impute income in circumstances such as diverted income, failure to provide required information, or unreasonable expense deductions. An expense does not become reasonable for support purposes merely because it was allowed for tax purposes.


Three questions often organize the analysis


1. What did the spouse receive personally?


Salary alone may not tell the whole story. Relevant items may include dividends, management fees, personal expenses paid by the business, shareholder-loan activity, vehicle or housing benefits, and payments made to related people or companies. Each item needs an explanation.


2. What stayed in the business—and why?


Money retained in a corporation may be needed for working capital, taxes, debt payments, inventory, equipment, seasonal swings or planned expansion. Evidence of those needs matters. So does the owner’s ability to decide whether money is paid out or retained.

The right question is not simply, “How much cash is in the company?” It is whether personal income, considered with the company’s finances and legitimate operating requirements, fairly reflects money available for support.


3. Are the claimed expenses reasonable in context?


Self-employed people are entitled to incur real business expenses. The issue is whether a deduction is genuinely connected to earning business income, reasonable in amount, and free of a significant personal benefit that should be considered for support.

Vehicle, travel, meals, home-office, telephone, insurance and payments to family members can require closer review. That does not mean they are automatically improper. It means the supporting invoices, business purpose, allocation and pattern may matter.


What records can clarify the picture?


For child-support cases, the Guidelines require three years of personal income tax returns and notices of assessment or reassessment. Self-employed people may also need to provide business financial statements and a breakdown of payments or benefits to people or corporations with whom they do not deal at arm’s length. A person who controls a corporation may need to provide the corporation’s and subsidiaries’ financial statements for the three most recent taxation years, together with related-party payment information.

Depending on the actual dispute, useful follow-up records may include corporate tax returns, current interim statements, general ledgers, shareholder-loan accounts, payroll and dividend records, business bank and credit-card statements, and documents supporting significant or unusual expenses.


The request should be tied to an issue. Asking for every business record ever created can be expensive and slow. Asking only for a T1 may be too narrow. A focused disclosure plan identifies the uncertainty first, then requests the records most likely to answer it.


An example


Hypothetical example: A spouse reports $72,000 of personal income. Their corporation also earned profit and paid vehicle and travel costs. The other spouse believes income should be much higher.


That belief is not enough by itself, but it identifies questions worth testing. Were the vehicle and travel costs business-related, personal, or mixed? Was the remaining corporate income needed for payroll, taxes or equipment? Did the owner control distributions? Was the year typical? Were payments made to a family member at a reasonable rate?


When is an accountant or valuator useful?


Not every case needs an expert. A lawyer can often begin by identifying the legal issue, organizing the disclosure and narrowing disputed entries. If the corporation is complex, the records conflict, or the amounts justify the cost, an accountant, Chartered Business Valuator or forensic specialist may help trace payments, normalize earnings or explain business requirements.


Income for support and the value of a business for property division are related but different questions. The same financial records may inform both, but care is needed to avoid counting the same economic value twice.


What about spousal support?


Self-employed income can also affect spousal support. Income is only one part of that analysis: entitlement, compensatory and non-compensatory factors, duration and the parties’ circumstances also matter. A support-income review should not be mistaken for a complete spousal-support opinion.


What can you do now?


Start with the documents you already have and a short list of concrete discrepancies. Note the business entities involved, the spouse’s roles, the income sources reported, significant expenses, changes from year to year and the specific questions the records do not answer.

Early legal advice can help decide whether ordinary disclosure is enough, whether a targeted request is proportionate, and whether expert accounting work is likely to add value. That can be useful whether you are questioning the other spouse’s income or trying to explain your own business finances fairly.


The Family Law Office of Isaac Paonessa offers focused strategy consultations and, in appropriate cases, defined-scope help with financial disclosure. The available options and qualifications are outlined on the firm’s Legal Fees and Service Options page.


Isaac advises clients in London, St. Thomas, Kitchener-Waterloo, Sarnia, Chatham and elsewhere in Ontario on support, disclosure and complex financial issues. A consultation can help identify the next practical step without assuming that every case requires full representation or a forensic investigation.


Frequently asked questions


Is the income on a Notice of Assessment the income used for support?


It is often an important starting point, but it may not be the final figure. The Guidelines permit adjustments, multi-year review, consideration of corporate income and, in appropriate circumstances, imputation of income.


Can every business expense be added back?


No. Legitimate and reasonable business expenses should not be treated as personal income simply because they reduce profit. The issue is whether an expense is reasonable for support purposes and whether it provides a personal benefit.


Are retained earnings automatically included in income?


No. The analysis considers control, the corporation’s pre-tax income and legitimate business requirements. Evidence explaining why funds were retained is important.


Do I need a forensic accountant?


Not necessarily. Begin by defining the disputed issue and reviewing the required disclosure. Expert help may be proportionate where the structure is complex, the records are unreliable or the amount at stake justifies the cost.


Can support income change from year to year?


Yes. Self-employed earnings can fluctuate, and the Guidelines allow a court to consider patterns over three years where using one year would not be the fairest determination.


This article provides general information about Ontario family law. It is not legal advice. The appropriate analysis depends on the facts, the records and the governing law at the time advice is given.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page